Surface area and boil vigor are going to be the main considerations. I find that the bigger the batch size, the more accurate Tinseth's formula becomes. If you're using Rager, then just switch. After that, just add a little more utilization to the equipment profile.
The main thing is to make sure that you compare two versions of a recipe you've made a lot. Like a pale ale that doesn't have more than 50 IBUs. It's simply easier to taste 5 IBU differences when you stay between 20 and 50 IBU.
If your hopping is mostly burst or whirlpool, then the main difference is heat carryover, post boil. In that case, you're detecting more CoHumulone isomerization because that's the first AA to isomerize and has the coarsest texture on the palate.