I 've made 4 pumpkin ales this past fall, 2 with a brown ale base and 2 with a pale ale base. In the lighter versions I used 8 lbs of maris otter and 1 lbs of 40l crystal malt. Even though your using pumpkin (I've always used fresh) ,it,'s the spices that come through. Allspice,cinnamon,nutmeg, and a touch of clove, cloves can be overwhelming if used in excess.
That said I preferred the lighter base better. Actually the color is a bright copper which looks alot like pumpkin. But there is more than one way to skin a cat, ain't there?
good brewin'