how much hops are you adding? how many minutes are you boiling for? what is the alpha acid % for the hops? what is your utilization factor? (should be 100% for home sized batches)
these are the settings that will control how many IBU you get from any particular addition.
add to that the method of calculation (I think there are two major ones Tinseth and Rager) which will change the number.
I don't have beersmith on this computer so I can't direct you to particular areas but the boil minutes, acid %, and amount are right in the entry on the recipe. the utilization factor is in settings I beleive, or the equipment profile.