THANK YOU Oginme!
"So I recently switched from light dme to extra light dme (Pilsner). I've done 2 batches so far, and my OGs are WAY off. Last batch was 1.072 instead of 1.060, and the batch I did tonight was 1.070 instead of 1.058. Used 7.5 lbs in last batch, and 7 lbs tonight. Topped off to 5 gallons both times and stirred and stirred before taking the sample. Last batch came out great, fermented to 1.016. It was a little sweet, but the hop flavors were money. The wort from tonight's batch tasted great, but why the $%# are my OGs so off?"
I could not for the life of me figure out why. I searched through every setting I could think of in my equipment profile. Nothing seemed to change my target OG. Until it dawned on me that I was steeping 2 lbs of grain. Obviously I am getting fermentables from that! Changed profile to "partial mash" and BAM. My 2 target OGs changed to 1.072, which is what I was hitting!
Thanks again dude.