This week I take a look at what to do if your water source is simply too high in mineral content and ways you can compensate to brew great beer.
My Struggle with Bad Water
Back in the 1990’s when I first started brewing all grain beers, I lived in the mountains outside of Albuquerque, New Mexico where unfortunately the water was very high in mineral content. It was so hard, that we had to use bottled water to make coffee. I ended up also purchasing bottled water to make beer as the water was simply not usable for brewing.
Understanding Your Existing Brewing Water
Our knowledge base for brewing has expanded significantly in the last 30 years, so now we know a lot more about what to do about hard water or water that simply has high ion content. I would recommend that you first get your water tested for the big six water ions using a reputable test kit or lab that provides a brewing water report. This will give you a definitive measure of just how good or bad your water is.
With your water report you should get a measure of each of the following water ions in parts per million (ppm) or mg/l which are approximately the same thing. Here’s a guide for what each of the ions does and also the range that is acceptable for brewing:
- Calcium (Ca) [50-100 ppm] – Acidifies the mash and drives down the mash pH which is generally a good thing in lighter color beers. It also aids in precipitating phosphates and improving the stability of the beer. Calcium also provides some structure to the beer and is used in that role as well.
- Bicarbonate (HCO3) [0-250 ppm] or Alkalinity [0-200 ppm] – Strongly alkaline so it will raise the mash pH which is undesirable in lighter color beers. High levels also will impede the cold break and emphasize bitterness in a harsh way. The main role for these ions is in mash pH balance, and too much alkalinity can be undesirable. You can convert from bicarbonate to alkalinity using this equation: alkalinity = bicarbonate * 50 / 61
- Sulfate (SO4) [50-250 ppm] – Suilfate enhances bitterness in beer and slightly lightens color. Its primarily role is as a counterbalance to chloride in determining the sulfate/chloride ratio which affects bitterness perception in the final beer.
- Chloride (Cl) [0-250 ppm] – Chloride will lower the bitterness perception and enhance the maltiness of the beer. Its major role, along with sulfate, is in determining the sulfate/chloride ratio which affects bitterness perception in the beer.
- Sodium (Na) [0-150 ppm] – Sodium provides enhances the sweetness and body in certain dark beers. However it is not a major player in mash pH so it is primarily used to provide some roundness in darker beers.
- Magnesium (Mg) [10-40 ppm] – Magnesium plays an important role in fermentation as it is needed by yeast, but grains in the mash do provide about 100ppm of magnesium. However, recent research indicates that calcium may actually block the yeast’s access to magnesium if it is very high. So it may be important to keep the total magnesium levels (water plus magnesium from the mash) above the calcium to enhance yeast health. Magnesium also plays a small role in mash pH, but is largely overshadowed by bicarbonate and sulfate.
When looking at the ranges above, you need to keep in mind that those are general guidelines and the actual water profile needed will vary by style. For example, 200ppm bicarbonate might be perfectly acceptable in a stout but would not work well in a light continental lager. BeerSmith software has a series of water profiles under Ingredients->Water by city and style which you can use for a guide.
The Blunt Force Approach – Replace Hard Water
If your water is indeed unsuitable for brewing, you can take a blunt force approach and replace it with mineral water, distilled water or install a RO water system. In the case of distilled or RO water you also need to add some water salts to build the water profile back up to your desired profile. BeerSmith has tools built in to help you calculate which salts to add to best match your water profile. There is an article on it here and also a video showing the process for matching a water profile from a base water. These tools make it easy to adjust RO or distilled water to match a given profile.
Diluting Your Hard Water
There is one big limitation to using the water salts when brewing. Adding water salts can only increase the water ion content, it can’t remove ions from existing water. So if you want to reduce the ion content in your water you need to either replace it or dilute it with water that has a lower ion content. RO and Distilled water both have nearly zero ion content so these are the best candidates.
Rather than purchasing 100% bottled water, you can instead dilute your hard water with distilled or RO water until the ion content is below that of the water profile you are targeting and then use a tool like BeerSmith to adjust the water profile using salts as needed. If you use distilled or RO water the calculation is fairly straighforward as these contain close to zero ions and relationship is linear with the water volumes used.
What this means is if you use 50% distilled water and 50% hard water from your tap it will cut your water ion content roughly in half. If you use 75% distilled water you will cut your water ion values by 75%, and so on. Your goal is to simply get the water ion content for all of the “big six” ions below your target water profile so you only need to use enough distilled or RO water to achieve that goal, and then you can use the match water profile tools linked in above to estimate the salts needed for a good match.
In BeerSmith you can experiment with various mixes of distilled/RO water and your hard water profile easily. First go to Ingredients->Water and add a new water profile that matches your water report and label it something like “My Local Water”. Next when you are building a recipe you can go over to the Water tab and add your base water profile to the base water box. Next add some RO or distilled water to the base water box so you have two entries now.
Now you can play with the water volumes of each to get the mix you want, while matching the total water needed. For example if your total water needed is 7 gallons and you want to try a 50-50% split you can try 3.5 gallons of each. BeerSmith will calculate the diluted water profile and show it in the overall base water profile at the bottom of the base water box. As long as this base water profiles ion content is below that of the target water profile you want to use you can go on and use the Match Target Water Profile button to estimate the salts needed.
So working with a hard water profile is a two step process:
- Dilute the Hard Water: Use the base water profile box to enter both your hard water and a distilled water ingredient, then adjust the volumes so the total matches the total water needed for the beer, but your base water profile shown near the bottom of the box has all of its ions below the target water profile you want for the beer.
- Add Salts to Match Your Target: Use the Match a Target Water Profile button to select a target profile and BeerSmith will estimate the best water salts to use and add them as ingredients for the recipe. This is covered in this article or this video.
I hope you enjoyed this week’s article on tips for brewing with hard water. Thanks for joining me on the BeerSmith Home Brewing Blog. If you want to take the guesswork out of brewing, please try my BeerSmith 4 recipe software from BeerSmith.com. Be sure to sign up for my newsletter or my podcast (also on itunes and youtube) for more great tips on homebrewing.

